Skip to content
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Passport
  • Support WSKG
Donate
  • Donate
  • logo
  • logo
  • Donate
  • Home
  • News
  • TV
  • Your Radio
  • Schedules
  • Events
  • Arts
  • Education
  • History
  • Science
  • Donate
  • More
    • About
    • Contact Us
    • Passport
    • Support WSKG

WSKG - Local news and arts, broadcasting NPR radio and PBS TV.

WSKG thanks our sponsors...
  • Donate your vehicle to support WSKG

WSKG (https://wskg.org/news/new-york-court-upholds-end-of-religious-exemptions-for-vaccines/)

  • Donate
  • Home
  • News
  • TV
  • Your Radio
  • Schedules
  • Events
  • Arts
  • Education
  • History
  • Science
Listen Live WSKG
Listen Live WSKG Classical

Watch Live WSKG TV
Watch Live PBS Kids
Learn at Home
Covid-19 information

New York Court Upholds End Of Religious Exemptions For Vaccines

By Brett Dahlberg | November 7, 2019
More
  • More on binghamton
  • Subscribe to binghamton

ROCHESTER, NY (WXXI) – A state appeals court in Seneca County has upheld New York’s elimination of religious exemptions to vaccine requirements.

The ruling from State Supreme Court Justice Daniel Doyle rejected claims that eliminating the exemptions was an unconstitutional infringement on religious rights.

This is the first school year in which a medical exemption form signed by a doctor is the only way around vaccination requirements for students enrolled in public, private or parochial schools in New York.

The case in Seneca County focused on an Amish family represented by Long Island attorney Jason Mermigis. In his initial complaint, Mermigis said the family’s three children are all unvaccinated, and all attend Cranberry Marsh school in Romulus, a town about midway between Rochester and Syracuse.

All 24 of the students at the private school are unvaccinated, the complaint said. Forcing the children to be vaccinated would be a “betrayal of faith in God” for their father, Jonas Stoltzfus, Mermigis wrote.

“I think that’s a serious, you know, infringement of religious freedoms and religious rights,” Mermigis said.

Mermigis said the ruling left him “shocked.”

“I think this decision is callous. I think it’s ignorant,” he said.

The state health department said it cannot comment on pending litigation. Under the rules barring religious exemptions to vaccines, schools can be fined up to $2,000 per day for each student who is out of compliance.

A health department spokesperson said she did not have information immediately available about whether the state had taken any punitive action against Cranberry Marsh school.

Mermigis said the family lives in a secluded community, and they would not put anyone else at risk by being unvaccinated.

But Seneca County public health director Vickie Swinehart said Amish communities often have contact with other populations.

“They’re not totally isolated,” she said. “They still go out to stores and are in the general population. They’re not just in their own community and stay there. They interact – you know, the Amish work in the community. Some of them – they’re not all just farmers who work on their farm and don’t go anywhere.”

Swinehart said increasing the vaccination rate is important to protect Amish families and others. She says diseases like measles and whooping cough are extremely contagious.

Swinehart and other public health officials in largely rural Finger Lakes counties said they have been scheduling additional outreach sessions to talk to Amish and Mennonite families about the new rules and the benefits of vaccines.

“These are communities with traditionally some of the lowest rates of immunization,” said Yates County deputy public health director Sara Christensen.

Even when families are on board with the new rules, though, actually getting their children up-to-date on vaccines is a struggle, Christensen said.

“We started our efforts this summer, and we are still working to reach some families,” she said.

Mermigis said the Stoltzfus family probably doesn’t know about the ruling yet. He said they call him from a community phone once a week, and when they talk next, he’ll tell them about the judge’s decision and see if they want to take further legal action.

Recent Posts

  • Poll: New Yorkers On The Fence About Cuomo

    ALBANY, NY (WAMC) - There are mixed results for embattled New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo in the latest poll from the Siena College Research Institute. The poll released Monday showed the governor's favorability rating remains under water, by a margin of 40% to 52%.

  • A view of the Greenidge Generation plant with steam billowing from one of two cooling towers
    Torrey Board To Consider Greenidge Cryptocurrency Plan Monday

    Updated: 4/16/21 – 2:15 P.M. ENDWELL, NY (WSKG) — The fate of Greenidge Generation’s plan to expand cryptocurrency mining operations at its power facility along Seneca Lake will be decided by the Town of Torrey Planning Board Monday. Environmental advocates have been pushing back against the proposal, which they allege will lead to increased greenhouse gas emissions by the plant and other detrimental impacts.

  • Boost In State Aid Gives New York School Districts Much Needed Help

    SYRACUSE, NY (WRVO) - Local school districts are getting a much-needed financial boost, thanks to the recently passed New York state budget. The spending plan includes a record $29.5 billion for school aid, an 11% increase.

  • Election Experts Recommend What PA Counties Long Wanted: More Ballot Pre-Canvassing Time

    HARRISBURG, PA (WSKG) –– Panels of voting advocates and researchers have offered state lawmakers a broad range of ideas for improving Pennsylvania’s election code in the last few months. But no change was more widely-proffered than the idea to let counties have more time to sort, open and prepare mail-in ballots ahead of Election Day.

  • Starting In June, New York Will Require $15 High-Speed Internet for Low-Income Families

    NEW YORK NOW - Large internet service providers will be required to officer plans for high-speed connections at $15 per month to low-income customers starting in the middle of June after legislation on the mandate was signed into law Friday. New York state will also partner with philanthropic organizations to provide free high-speed internet access to 50,000 students in low-income school districts for one year.

WSKG thanks our sponsors...

About WSKG

WSKG connects you to local and global news and the arts online, on the radio, and on TV. NPR and PBS affiliate.

Contact Us

email: WSKGcomment@wskg.org

phone: 607.729.0100

address: 601 Gates Road, Vestal, NY 13850

DONATE

Pay an underwriting invoice

  • WSKG
  • Arts
  • Education
  • Science
  • News
  • Your Radio
  • Schedule
  • TV
  • About
  • WSKG Staff
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs
  • Public Reports & Policies
  • Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO)
  • Protect My Public Media
FCC PUBLIC FILES
WSKG-FM
WSQX-FM
WSQG-FM
WSQE
WSQA
WSQC-FM
WSQN
WSKG-TV
WSKA
Disabled and need assistance with the online FCC public file?
Contact Gregory Keeler
WSKG
601 Gates Road
Vestal, New York 13850
607-729-0100
gkeeler@wskg.org

Stay Connected

Like Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on YouTubeFollow Us on InstagramSubscribe via RSS

© Copyright 2021, WSKG

Built with the Largo WordPress Theme from the Institute for Nonprofit News.

Back to top ↑

Change Location
To find awesome listings near you!