© 2025 WSKG

601 Gates Road
Vestal, NY 13850

217 N Aurora St
Ithaca, NY 14850

FCC LICENSE RENEWAL
FCC Public Files:
WSKG-FM · WSQX-FM · WSQG-FM · WSQE · WSQA · WSQC-FM · WSQN · WSKG-TV · WSKA
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

How a grandmother helped her granddaughter to find her voice

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

It's Friday, which is when we hear from StoryCorps, and we have a story now that stretches across time. Mary Lee McNelis was born with significant developmental delays. By age 6, she still wasn't speaking. That's when her grandmother, Phyllis, a retired public school teacher, stepped in. Here is a recording from almost 20 years ago when she sat down with Mary Lee's mom, Laura.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

LAURA LIVINGSTONE-MCNELIS: I had heard for the umpteenth time from another professional that she was never going to speak, that we should just give up. So I called you, and you said, no, you can't give up. You asked me if I would be open to Mary Lee coming to stay with you that summer, and you would try to make something happen.

PHYLLIS KNIGHTON: Mary drew my heart because the lack of language set her apart socially from other children. As a child, I knew what it was like to be lonely or cut off from people. So I went back to school, the oldest person on campus, I think...

(LAUGHTER)

KNIGHTON: ...And took courses in speech therapy. But I didn't know if I'd be able to help Mary or not.

LIVINGSTONE-MCNELIS: I remember she had a little Peter Rabbit book that you had given to her, and I realized she never looked at the pictures, but she always looked at the words. And I found that fascinating because to a little child, they would just be squiggly lines on a page. And you said, you just watch. She's going to be a good reader. And you were right.

KNIGHTON: We discovered that seeing it in print gave her the use of the words. It started out with a very simple story, like, Mary has a doll. Mary likes the doll. I read it to her, and Mary read it back to me. And then in two weeks, Mary wrote a letter, and she read it to you on the phone.

LIVINGSTONE-MCNELIS: That was the first time I'd ever heard her speak. She said, dear Mama, how are you? I love you. From Mary. I'd never heard her say I love you before. She'd always signed it to me, and I knew she felt it. I couldn't stay away any longer. I drove right over to where you were. And I just had to be there to witness this miracle that was starting to happen.

KNIGHTON: Well, Mary is a miracle. There's so many wonderful things about her. I love Mary Lee so much, and I've always been so proud of you.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

INSKEEP: Phyllis Knighton from almost 20 years ago. She has since died, but recently, Laura sat down with her daughter Mary Lee, who's now an adult.

MARY LEE MCNELIS: How do I remind you of Grandma?

LIVINGSTONE-MCNELIS: Oh, my gosh. You and Grandma are kindred spirits. You have her energy and her optimism. You bring sunshine and light into every room.

MCNELIS: Oh, thank you.

LIVINGSTONE-MCNELIS: After she passed away, I went outside onto the deck, and I heard you talking. And it was dark out. And then I realized you were looking up, and you were speaking to Grandma, right?

MCNELIS: Yes.

LIVINGSTONE-MCNELIS: And what do you say to Grandma when you look up at the stars?

MCNELIS: Hey, Grandma, how are you doing today? I'm so glad that you taught me how to talk.

LIVINGSTONE-MCNELIS: You were telling her that one day you'll meet again in heaven.

MCNELIS: Yes, that we will meet in heaven.

LIVINGSTONE-MCNELIS: And someday you will, and she'll be overjoyed.

MCNELIS: Yes.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

INSKEEP: Mary Lee McNelis, Laura Livingstone-McNelis and Phyllis Knighton, Kalamazoo. Their conversation is at the Library of Congress. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.

Jo Corona