CIA Director Mike Pompeo is on track to make history this week, but probably not in the way his supporters envisioned.
The secretary of state-designate’s nomination is unlikely to be favorably recommended out of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee Monday night because no Democrat on the 11-10 panel supports his nomination, and neither does Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky.
Sen. Chris Coons, D-Del., was the latest committee Democrat to come out against the nomination, stating concerns on Friday that Pompeo — who Democrats regard as a military hawk — will embolden “President Trump’s most belligerent and dangerous instincts.”
Democrats also point to Pompeo’s past positions, including his opposition to the Iran nuclear deal when he served in Congress, as evidence that he is not qualified to be America’s top diplomat.
“I cannot overlook grave doubts about his anti-diplomacy disposition,” said Sen. Tim Kaine, D-Va., in a statement opposing Pompeo, even though he was one of 14 Democrats who voted in favor of his previous nomination for his current post at CIA.
An unfavorable recommendation out of committee has no practical effect. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., still intends to hold a full Senate confirmation vote this week, but the absence of an affirmative committee vote is unprecedented for a State Department nominee, according to the Senate Historical Office.
“We’re going to vote on Monday night, and I agree with you that it doesn’t look promising as far as an affirmative vote,” Senate Foreign Relations Chairman Bob Corker, R-Tenn., told reporters on Friday. He chalked up Democratic opposition to partisan election year politics, and not a statement on Pompeo’s qualifications.
“It’s just the environment we’re in. The left, the base on the Democratic side abhors the president, and I realize many of them just don’t want to do anything that shows a proxy of support for Trump by voting for his secretary of state,” Corker said. “I really do think Pompeo is highly qualified, and I think in their heart of hearts, truth serum wise, [Democrats] would probably agree.”
One Democrat, North Dakota’s Heidi Heitkamp, announced Friday she would back Pompeo’s nomination, signaling Pompeo likely has the support needed on the Senate floor.
“Pompeo demonstrated during this nomination process and during our meeting in March that he is committed to empowering the diplomats at the State Department so they can do their jobs in advancing American interests,” Heitkamp said in a statement.
With a narrow Republican 51-49 majority (Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., absent, and Paul opposed), McConnell likely has 49 votes in favor of the nomination. Sen. Jeff Flake, R-Ariz., has not publicly committed to supporting Pompeo, but his GOP colleagues are confident he ultimately will vote for his nomination. Heitkamp’s support would clinch 50 votes, and with the support of Vice President Pence, Pompeo could be confirmed.
Additional Democratic support is possible. Seven Democrats remained publicly uncommitted, including other Red State Democrats up for re-election this year, such as Sens. Joe Donnelly of Indiana, Joe Manchin of West Virginia, and Claire McCaskill of Missouri. Democrats are under pressure from progressive activist groups such as MoveOn and NARAL to oppose the nomination.
Historically, secretaries of state have enjoyed large, bipartisan margins of support. Senators have generally held the view that presidents are allowed to have the Cabinet of their choosing as long as there are no glaring problems with the nominees. Both Secretaries Hillary Clinton and John Kerry were confirmed with 94 votes in support under President Barack Obama. Secretary Condoleezza Rice was confirmed with 85 votes, and Secretary Colin Powell was so popular it didn’t even require a roll call — the Senate approved it by a voice vote — under President George W. Bush.
President Trump has not fared as well. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson won approval with just 56 votes in favor of his nomination, the most votes against a state nominee in Senate history. Later this week, Pompeo might test that record.
Republicans like Corker shrug at the prospect of a historically low vote.
“I mean, at the end of the day, whether the committee gives a negative recommendation and you still get 50 votes on the floor, even if it takes the vice president, you’re still secretary of state and all of this dissipates,” he said.