Aaron Reid is lying in a hospital bed at the National Institutes of Health when doctors arrive to make sure he’s ready for his experimental treatment.
“How’s your night? Any issues?” asks Dr. Katherine Barnett, a pediatric oncologist, as they begin to examine Reid.
Reid, 20, of Lucedale, Miss., has been fighting leukemia ever since he was nine years old. He’s been through chemotherapy and radiation twice, a bone marrow transplant and two other treatments.
But the leukemia keeps coming back. This time, the cancer is all over his body. He can feel the pain in his bones. He’s here today for what could be his last hope.
“The big plan for the day: Get the cells,” says Dr. Andrea Gross, another pediatric oncologist.
The cells are an experimental version of a relatively new cancer therapy called CAR-T. These CAR-T cells are sometimes called “living drugs” because they are engineered from patients’ own immune system cells.
“I think it’s amazing that they can find a way to use someone’s own … cells,” Reid says. “Take out their own cells, teach it to do something and then put it back in them, and to be able to heal them. I think that’s amazing.”
The engineered cells are made by extracting T cells — a key part of the immune system — from each patient’s blood and then genetically modifying them in the lab. The T cells that are created carry structures on their surface called chimeric antigen receptors, or CAR for short. Those receptors enable the cells to zero in and attack cancer.
“What we’re doing is we are educating [the T cells] to say, ‘These things don’t belong,'” says Dr. Nirali Shah, a pediatric oncologist at the National Cancer Institute who is running a study Reid is in. ” ‘You need to get rid of them. Yes, I know that they started in the body. But they’re not supposed to be there. You need to attack.’ ”
Once the cells are infused back into a patient’s body, they take on a life of their own, increasing their numbers in proportion to the cancer in the body, Shah says.
“It’s an army that multiplies when it has a bigger job to do,” Shah says.
“It’s a living drug. It multiplies in the body.”
CAR-T therapies are among the most exciting developments in cancer research in years — one of several approaches that harness the immune system to fight cancer.
“It’s been a phenomenal success,” Shah says.
The Food and Drug Administration has already approved two CAR-T therapies. The first was for children and young adults suffering from acute lymphoblastic leukemia, which is the most common cancer among children. The agency subsequently approved a second CAR-T therapy for adults with a form of lymphoma.
But these “living drugs” are far from perfect. They’re very expensive, costing hundreds of thousands of dollars for each infusion for each patient.
“These are amazing drugs. But these are prices that we really haven’t seen before,” says Dr. Peter Bach, who directs the Center for Health Policy and Outcomes at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York. “It’s just astonishing how comfortable people have gotten with treatments costing these astronomical sums.”
The treatments can also be dangerous, sometimes triggering what can be a life-threatening reaction by the immune system.
Another significant issue is that CAR-T cells may not work very well on some of the most common solid cancers, such as tumors of the breast, lung or prostate.
“The first attempts to apply CAR therapy to solid tumors, which I found premature, have not been very impressive,” says Dr. Michel Sadelain, a leading CAR researcher at Memorial Sloan Kettering.
And even for leukemia and lymphoma, the cancer often comes back. That’s what happened to Aaron after every treatment he tried, including another form of CAR-T.
“Leukemia is smart,” Shah says. “Our therapy is really good. But the leukemia has found a way to outsmart our really, really exciting therapy. And so we have to find a way to attack it differently.”
Scientists around the world are doing hundreds of studies to try to improve the CAR-T strategy. Some are trying to create off-the-shelf CAR-T cells that won’t have to be made individually for each patient. That approach is being developed to make them much easier to produce and much less expensive.
Shah’s team is testing an experimental CAR-T approach designed to reduce the risk of a recurrence. Her team is modifying patients’ T cells to recognize and attack two targets unique to leukemia cells instead of just one. The two CAR-T treatments approved so far have been engineered to target just one. The hope is that adding a second will reduce the risk of a relapse.
“One of my patients calls it the one-two punch,” Shah says. “Maybe we can really get at the leukemia and prevent one of those leukemia cells from outsmarting the immune therapy — get rid of each and every single one so that there’s no chance for even one of those little buggers from escaping and coming back at a later time.”
In preparation for Reid’s infusion, technicians in a lab at the NIH hospital pull open a huge metal tank and slide out Aaron’s genetically engineered cells. After testing, checking and rechecking the cells, they fill a large plastic syringe with 17 million of Aaron’s tailor-made cells and rush them to Aaron’s room.
Once there, the nurses confirm one more time that they’ve got the right cells for the right patient. They take Reid’s temperature and check his blood pressure.
“I just wanted to check in — make sure there are no any additional questions,” Shah says.
“Let’s get it over with,” Reid says.
The nurse leans over Reid holding the syringe with his cells. He inserts the tip into a tube that was placed in Reid’s chest earlier, and begins squeezing the plunger.
As the cells slowly drip into Reid’s body, the nurses watch his vital signs to make sure he’s not having a bad reaction.
And after about five minutes, it’s done.
Aaron’s doctors will now monitor Reid closely for the first signs the treatment is starting to work. Within a few weeks, the CAR-T cells should kick into high gear and cause his immune system to explode like a storm, Shah says.
“The first hint of a fever and achiness and things like that, we get really excited because it means the storm is coming,” Shah says. “But along with the storm it means that the cells are getting activated and they are going to start doing their job.”
That storm, technically known as cytokine-release syndrome, can be extremely intense, and sometimes it’s life-threatening. But doctors have learned how to manage the reaction in most patients, Shah says.
“So now we wait,” Shah whispers almost to herself as she heads back to her office.
For his part, Reid is optimistic.
“This is all kind of really exciting stuff. Don’t know what’s going to happen,” he says. “Hopefully it works.”